Which Natural Sleep Aid is Right For You?

When we think of insomnia, we often imagine a person pushed to the brink of sanity, tossing and turning each night without getting a wink of sleep. Could it be stress? Time zone changes? Mineral imbalances? Perhaps there is more to the Princess and the Pea fable.

The 1835 fable by Hans Christian Andersen suggested that the true princess was the one who felt the pea under her twenty feather beds—but was that really why she tossed and turned all night?

Many people struggle to get the sleep they want because of specific biological issues that need to be addressed. Natural sleep aids can help almost anyone improve sleep, but each has different uses. The right choice depends on what keeps you awake. Even if your sleep feels adequate now, imagine how you would feel after a great night’s sleep every night.

Why Should I Be Concerned About My Sleep?

Stress reduces your body's ability to sleep

One common source of sleep difficulty is elevated cortisol levels throughout the day. Normally, cortisol is highest in the morning and gradually decreases into the evening. As levels drop, the body relaxes and prepares for rest, supporting a healthy sleep cycle.

Cortisol regulates metabolism, insulin and blood sugar levels, sex hormone production, blood pressure, bone formation, wound healing, and immune and digestive function. When cortisol follows its natural rhythm, we feel energized during the day and able to sleep at night.

Stressful situations late in the day—and caffeine—can increase cortisol and disrupt this rhythm. Chronic stress, whether from work pressure, family issues, or ongoing worry, can prevent cortisol from decreasing at night.

If cortisol remains elevated in the evening, insomnia and other health issues may result. Symptoms of high cortisol can include anxiety, fatigue, depression, high blood pressure, rapid weight gain (especially in the face and abdomen), skin changes, and muscle weakness.

Sleep reduces mistakes and improves reaction time

A study published in Seminars in Neurology found that 28 hours of sleep deprivation impaired performance and reaction time similarly to a blood alcohol level of 0.10. Even after 16 hours awake, impairment resembled a blood alcohol level of 0.05–0.08. Research from The Lancet also found that one sleepless night increased surgical errors by 20–32%.

Sleep helps us lose weight

Research published in Annals of Internal Medicine shows that inadequate sleep disrupts appetite-regulating hormones leptin and ghrelin, increasing obesity risk. A University of Pennsylvania study found that sleep-restricted adults consumed about 500 extra calories during late-night hours.

Quality sleep also helps protect against chronic disease, migraines, and vision problems. Many people need more than the commonly recommended eight hours, with some requiring ten hours or more to function optimally.

Which Supplements Can Help?

5-HTP for insomnia related to depression or anxiety

Difficulty falling asleep due to anxious or depressed thoughts may be linked to low serotonin levels. Serotonin is a neurotransmitter that helps regulate mood and sleep. While serotonin cannot be taken directly, 5-HTP increases serotonin production naturally.

Research published in Alternative Medicine Review shows that 5-HTP (100–300 mg before bed) is well absorbed and effectively increases serotonin levels. Vitamin B6 supports this conversion and also contributes to melatonin production.

5-HTP Plus by Douglas Laboratories includes both 5-HTP and vitamin B6.

Melatonin for travelers and jet lag

Melatonin helps regulate the body’s sleep-wake cycle and is especially useful for adjusting internal clocks during travel. A review in the Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews found melatonin effective for preventing and reducing jet lag.

For eastward travel, take melatonin about 20 minutes before your target bedtime at your destination. Low doses such as 1 mg are usually sufficient.

Melatonin 1mg by Douglas Laboratories is a good low-dose option.

Magnesium for the athletically inclined

Magnesium is essential for bone, brain, and muscle function, yet many people are deficient. Research published in the International Journal of Research in Medical Sciences shows magnesium supplementation can improve sleep quality, duration, and ease of falling asleep.

Magnesium citrate is an affordable, highly absorbable form. I recommend Magnesium (citrate) by Pure Encapsulations.

Valerian for general sleep support

Valerian root has been used since ancient times to support sleep and calm the nervous system. It is believed to work by increasing levels of GABA, a neurotransmitter that promotes relaxation and sleepiness.

Studies published in the American Journal of Medicine and Pharmacopsychiatry found valerian improves sleep quality without the hangover effect common with pharmaceutical sleep aids.

Valerian works best when taken consistently over time. A high-potency option is Valerian Root by Vital Nutrients.

Help your sleep aid help you

Maintain a consistent bedtime and wake time, even on weekends. Avoid caffeine after mid-afternoon and large or spicy meals before bed. Exercise earlier in the day and limit screen exposure during the last hour before sleep.

For some, lifestyle changes are enough. For others, the right natural sleep aid can be life-changing. If sleep problems persist, choosing the appropriate support is key.

I hope this information is useful. If you have questions, contact our customer service team at customerservice@oakwaynaturals.com or call 888-460-3091.

Until next time, stay healthy!

Yours in health,

Dr. Gregg Gittins

When we think of insomnia, we often think of a person pushed to the brink of sanity that tosses and turns each night in bed without getting a wink of sleep. Could it be stress? Time zone changes? Imbalance of minerals?

Many struggle to get the sleep we want because of specific biological issues that need to be addressed. Natural sleep aids can help almost anyone improve their sleep, but they each have different uses and the right one for your situation depends on what keeps you up. It’s worth learning which is best for you because even if your sleep feels adequate now, imagine how you would feel if you had a great night’s sleep every night.

One common source of sleep difficulty results from elevated cortisol hormone levels at all times throughout the day. There is a normal pattern where the cortisol levels are higher in the morning and gradually decrease to their lowest levels in the evening. As our levels decrease, we begin to relax and rest. This allows the body to maintain a regular sleep cycle, or diurnal rhythm. When in a normal rhythm, we feel sharp, clear, and energized early in the day, and are able to get the sleep we need at night to take on the challenges of life.

However, long term stressors can cause cortisol levels to not decrease in the evenings as they should, and it can lead to insomnia and other significant health issues.

Getting better sleep simply helps us be the best we can be. Research from the University of Harvard and the University of Rochester found that the short-term productivity gains from skipping sleep to work are quickly negated by the negative effects of sleep deprivation on your ability to focus, remember, and access higher-level brain functions.

The research shows that sleep removes toxic proteins from the brain’s neurons that accumulate when we’re awake. An inability to sleep means that these proteins stay in the brain and cloud your thinking – no matter how much coffee you drink to try and counteract it.

Sleep helps us lose weight

Researchers have long believed that sleeplessness leads to poor food choices, one study found that a long-term lack of adequate sleep disrupts our appetite-regulating hormones, leptin and ghrelin, which can lead to obesity. Another study found similar results when they noticed that adults eat about 500 additional calories during late-night hours when they are sleep restricted.

Sleep can also help protect us from numerous chronic diseases, reduce migraines, and avoid vision problems. Getting good sleep can help us in so many ways, but quality sleep can be hard to come by for many.

When insomnia is related to depression or anxiety

If you have trouble falling asleep due to depressed or anxious thinking, taking 5-HTP before bed may help you relax and get rest. A common link between depression, anxiety, and insomnia is serotonin deficiency. Serotonin is found naturally in the human body and is a neurotransmitter that carries nerve signals. 5-HTP is well-known as a natural alternative to anti-depressants, but it also works as a sleep aid for the same reason it boosts mood – by increasing serotonin levels.

Do you ever feel tired after eating all that turkey on Thanksgiving? 5-HTP gives us a similar effect because turkey contains tryptophan that is then converted into 5-HTP, which is then eventually turned into serotonin.

Melatonin can help travelers/those with jet lag

Melatonin is commonly used as an all-purpose natural sleep aid, but research is conflicted on whether or not it is effective when used this way.

Melatonin’s primary function in the body is to regulate night and day cycles (also called sleep-wake cycles). Darkness makes the body create more melatonin, which tells the body it needs to begin its preparations for sleep. When it is light, less melatonin is made and this serves as the body’s signal to prepare for being awake.

Supplemental melatonin is believed to work by adjusting your internal clock when you take it, which makes it great for getting to sleep at an earlier time than you are accustomed.

Valerian is good for general use

If none of the other supplements spoke directly to your condition, valerian root extract is likely your best option.

Studies show that valerian is a safe, gentle, and effective natural sleep aid for people looking to fall asleep faster and stay asleep. The American Journal of Medicine recently analyzed the existing studies and research on valerian and found that valerian can improve sleep quality and is a better choice than many other sleep aids because of the lack of a “hangover” effect that follows most pharmaceutical prescriptions.

Valerian is most effective when taken long-term, so have patience with it. Many of the studies that prove valerian’s effectiveness note that single doses of valerian do not do much; the benefits come after multiple uses.

Help your sleep aid help you

There are other natural ways to help you get to sleep as well. As tempting as it is, avoid sleeping in or staying up late on weekends or days off. Going to bed and waking up at a consistent time is crucial for maintaining your internal sleep/wake clock. Exercise early in the day and the right dietary habits, such as avoiding coffee and caffeine past mid-afternoon and big or spicy meals before bed, can also help.

Don’t exercise late in the day, as it will increase that naturally occurring cortisol in your body that will make you stay awake.

Also remember to put away all electronics in the last hour before bed, since the light from these devices can stimulate the brain when it should be calming down.

Fortunately, in March 2016, Apple was the first to introduce enhancements to smartphones and tablets that have the ability to (based upon the clock and geolocation) automatically shift the colors on the display to the warmer end of the spectrum so as not to impact your circadian rhythm. Other electronics with screens such as TVs are sure to follow as this becomes a standard feature. 

We hope this slide show was helpful and informative. Should you have questions, or suggestions, please feel free to fill out our Ask the Doctor form found at the Doctors Corner.

 

Yours in health!

Dr. Gittins

 

References:

Committee on Sleep Medicine and Research, Sleep Disorders and Sleep Deprivation: An Unmet Public Health Problem. National Academies Press 2006

Birdsall, Timothy, N.D., Alternative Medicine Review: 5-Hydroxytryptophan: a clinically-effective serotonin precursor. 1998

Herxheimer, Andrew, M.D., and Petrie, Keith, Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews: Melatonin for the Prevention and Treatment of Jet Lag. 2002

Bent, Stephen, M.D., et al., American Journal of Medicine: Valerian for Sleep: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. 2015